When first reading August Wilson's The
Piano Lesson it is very easy to zero in on the topic of racism.
However I believe that is not the only major theme that exists in
this text. I do believe that the issue of sex and gender roles is an
underlying issue that is just as important to the play as the race
issue is.
Throughout the entirety of the play
Women (at least those who were forced to be slaves) are often revered
and remembered not only before their male counter parts, but in a
greater, almost divine light. There is even a scene that includes
Avery and Berniece have a fairly progressive talk about women,
especially since this play takes place in the 1930's. Also the scene
where Doaker explains their family heritage to Lymon is a good
example.
There is a scene in the play where
Uncle Doaker goes through their family tree explaining to Lymon about
it. The way he describes the males as oppose to the females is a bit
sexist . He has almost nothing good to say about any of the males in
the family aside from Papa Boy Charles, who physically sculpted the
piano, while saying almost nothing about the females of the family.
Now while he is not actually saying anything good or respectable
about the females, the lack of good things to be said about the males
of the family adds to the respectful demeanor of the females of the
family. He also explains how Papa Boy Charles' Wife and Son were
traded for a Piano. The fact that a woman slave was chosen over a
male slave also adds to the theme of gender roles. Due to the fact
that women can potentially give birth to more slaves.
Another point that adds to this theory
is the scene where Avery was trying to convince Berniece to marry
him. He says to her “Who you got to love you, Berniece?” when he
is proposing and saying he cannot wait forever. She then replays to
him by saying “You trying to tell me a woman can't be nothing
without a man. But you alright, huh? You can just walk out of here
without a woman and still be a man. That's alright. Ain't nobody
gonna ask you, “who you got to love you.”.” This is very
progressive thinking for the 1930's. This adds a great deal to the
theme of gender roles in the play.
The final scene is also a great
contribution to the theme of gender roles in the play. At the very
end of the play when Sutter's ghost is fighting with Boy Willie,
Berniece finally decides that she needs to play the piano. When she
does she sings a type of chant. When she is chanting she asks for
help from her ancestors, however the only ones she actually calls
upon are the women, with Papa boy Charles being the only exception
due to him being the one who carved the piano.
While looking at gender roles in this story, to add to your argument try taking a look at the women outside the family too. how they are barely there. We have a name for Grace who shows up twice in the play and she's just a material object for both Boy Willie and Lymon. Look at the way she acts and compare her to Berniece. While Berniece is strong and independent, Grace is spoiled and needy. "I ain't waiting on you. Told me you was coming right back. Now you got to move a piano. You just like all the other men." Grace dosn't care about anything but what she wants and the boys who will get it for her.
ReplyDeleteTo also further your argument, Lymon is always thinking about women. Or at least the characters in the play say so. It was easy for Wining Boy to convince Lymon to buy his silk suit and shoes so that he could find a woman. Wining Boy explains how Lymon's father was the same way. It seems as if the men in the play idolize women and view them as precious possessions.
ReplyDeleteGender roles in this play are just as important as the story of the piano itself. I agree with you that the women play a very important and strong role. Their importance gets somewhat overshadowed by the loud personality by Boy Willie and his determination to steal the piano but Berniece never lets us, the reader, forget that she also has a dominant presence and as you stated, calls upon the female ancestors to aid her in protecting the family and its history.
ReplyDeleteI completely agree with all of your statements on the importance of gender roles and how Wilson was emphasizing it through the text. It's nice to see that considering the setting of the play. Going along with your Doaker idea, he was always standing up for Berniece more than anyone else. He scolded Boy Willie for causing a disturbance when Berniece was trying to sleep, and he also specifically says that he respects the way Berniece is raising Maretha so he has never gone behind her back and told Maretha the story behind the piano.
ReplyDeleteThis is the first time I've read such a good blog, really very good,I hope there still can continue to read such a good blog.
ReplyDeleteCheap Piano Lessons